Press Releases

Letter from the Concerned Citizens of Belaga to the Deputy Prime Minister and SUHAKAM on Bakun's impacts on downstream communities (English)
3 July 2001


Concerned citizens from downstream of Balui River
c/o Ronald Bete Lahang
Lot No. 1048
Jalan Taman Tipong Tului
96900 Belaga
Sarawak

Yang Amat Berhormat
Datuk Seri Abdullah Ahmad Badawi
Timbalan Perdana Menteri Malaysia
Pejabat Timbalan Perdana Menteri
Aras 4, Blok Barat
Kompleks Jabatan Perdana Menteri
Pusat Pentadbiran Kerajaan Persekutuan
62502 Putrajaya.

Yang Berbahagia
Tan Sri Dato' Haji Anuar Dato' Haji Zainal Abidin
Pesuruhjaya Suruhanjaya Hak Asasi Malaysia
Tingkat 29 Menara Tun Razak
Jalan Raja Laut
50350 Kuala Lumpur 3 JULY 2001

Honourable Tan Sri/Datuk Seri,

Impacts of Bakun on downstream communities

We, a group of concerned citizens from the downstream area along the Balui River, would like to draw your attention to several important issues pertaining to the effects of the Bakun Hydroelectric Dam on riverine communities living downstream of the dam, which in our view, have been disregarded by the authorities.

We are deeply disappointed that these downstream communities, who include the people who live directly below the proposed dam and the residents of the Belaga township, have not been identified as communities who will be adversely affected by the project.

To this day, the authorities have yet to announce any plan that would take into account the consequences of Bakun on downstream communities, as part of the project's concerns with regards to its impacts on local communities. So far, there has been no preparation on the part of the authorities to design relevant action plans that are able to address the problems that may arise downstream in the future, as a result of the construction of the dam.

Thus we would like to take this opportunity to raise the various concerns that we have regarding the dam's impacts on downstream communities in the future. Below are the issues that we would like the authorities to look into:

Safety of the dam and downstream communities
Although we are aware of the existence of an Emergency Rescue Plan (ERP), which has been drawn up to prepare the concerned areas for the possible occurrence of dam failure, we have not been adequately informed of the procedures laid down by the plan.

Considering our vulnerable location, which is positioned exactly downstream of the dam, it is only natural that we harbour anxiety about the possibility of the dam suffering from any form of structural or functional failure for such a misfortune would surely result in huge financial losses for us and pose a threat to our safety and lives.

We are indeed extremely disappointed over the failure of the Government to address this urgent issue. It is clear that our welfare and rights have been seriously neglected in this matter.

The effects of the dam construction to the water quality and aquatic life downstream and the livelihood and health of downstream riverine communities.

The report of the World Commission on Dams (WCD) that was published in November 2000 explicitly states that the modified habitats created by large dams often develop environments that are more conducive to non-native and exotic plant and animal species that may often out-compete the population of native species of a river.

According to the report, such an ecosystem may become unstable, affect fishery resources and nurture disease vectors that can be harmful to both humans and other species. As a result of this, the river may no longer be able to support the historical, environmental, economic and social components of its downstream area.

Many examples from large dams from all over the world have demonstrated that these modified habitats could have severe consequences on communities who depend on the dammed river for their livelihood and way of life.

Worldwide, many communities living along the downstream terrains of large dams have had to face grave dangers and suffer economic losses as a result of the construction of the dams - from enduring the attack of serious skin infections to the loss of income.

Downstream pollution and other problems
As a result of the development of oil palm plantations and the resettlement area for relocated communities in Sungai Asap, we fear that downstream Balui River will gradually be polluted by organic contaminants and pesticides in the future. As it is today, the dam construction process itself has also, to a certain extent, affected the water quality of the Balui River.

In addition, we are also equally worried that our present river transportation system will be adversely affected by this project.

Thus, due to all of the distressing issues above, we, as residents living downstream of the Balui River, demand that:

The Government to comprehensively disseminate information on the content of the Emergency Rescue Plan (EPR) of the Bakun Hydroelectric Project to the people residing downstream of the dam.

A letter of undertaking to be issued to the downstream riverine communities to guarantee that in the event of any incidence of dam failure or damage, the Government or the project developer will be held accountable for the destruction and loss of properties and the suffering inflicted onto the communities.

This means that in the event of such an incidence, the Government or developer will bear the responsibility to pay adequate monetary compensation to the affected residents.

The Government to carry out an independent study on the water quality of downstream Balui River along with the latest status of its aquatic life and other possible impacts of the dam that may negatively affect the quality and habitat of the river in the future.
The authorities to carry out an investigation to determine whether the residents are facing a depletion in their supply of resources in their respective vicinities or will suffer from a loss of income in the future.
The Government to establish a comprehensive and meaningful consultation process with the downstream communities to inquire about their problems and wishes. In addition, the Government must also be willing to reasonably compensate residents whose livelihood has been affected by the construction of the dam.
Swift action to be taken to overcome the pollution of Balui River as a result of the construction of the dam.
Swift action must also be taken to ensure that the downstream communities will still be able to utilise the Balui River as their main transport system. If this is not possible, alternatively, a tarred road system must be provided for the downstream communities to replace their present main transport mode.
Before the planning and implementation of any comprehensive solutions or action plans, based upon the findings of the consultation process and the relevant independent studies, works at the dam site and the operation of the oil palm plantations in Sungai Asap must be halted.

We sincerely hope that the Government will be able to take the appropriate actions to fulfill our demands as soon as possible.

It is high time that the authorities begin to study the impacts of the development of Bakun Dam on downstream riverine communities and recognise that our access to a stable income and a healthy and safe way of life may be adversely affected in the future as a result of the project.

In addition, the Government must also continue to consult the concerned residents with a greater degree of openness so that prompt actions can be taken to protect their interests.
Thus, today we have travelled all the way from Belaga, Sarawak, to personally alert you on the problems that we face along with the demands that we have made.

Your kind attention is greatly appreciated.

Thank you.

Yours sincerely,

1. Bete Lahang - Uma Badang, Long Dungan, Belaga


2. Joseph Unak - Uma Aging


3. Sem Kiong Angin - Pasar Belaga


4. Lidom Jiu - Uma Punan Sama


5. Raymond Abin - Long Mejawali, Belaga


6. Semain Taja - Pasar Belaga